Will or gift deed: which is better for passing a parent's property to children in Karnataka?

In Short: A gift deed moves ownership now, needs registration, and generally cannot be undone once accepted. A will moves nothing until the parent dies, can be changed any number of times, and costs little to make. Within Bengaluru a gift of a flat to a close family member carries a fixed ₹5,000 stamp duty plus cess, surcharge and registration fee, so the choice is usually about control and family risk rather than tax.

Verify with your lawyer before acting. Gifts and wills decide who owns a home for decades. Have a property lawyer draft the document and advise on your family's situation, including any claims other heirs may have.

Verify with your CA before acting. Tax treatment of gifts and inherited property depends on the relationship and the facts. Confirm with a chartered accountant before you sign.

Families usually ask this when a parent wants to "settle things" while everyone gets along. Both routes work. They just put the risk in different places, and I find it helps to look at them the way you would look at any irreversible financial decision: what you give up, when, and what it costs to change your mind.

How does each one work?

Gift deed. Under sections 122 and 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, a gift of immovable property must be made by a registered instrument signed by the donor and attested by at least two witnesses, and the gift has to be accepted during the donor's lifetime. Once accepted, it can be revoked only in the narrow cases the law allows, such as an agreed condition that fails.

Will. Under section 63 of the Indian Succession Act, a will must be signed by the testator and attested by two witnesses. Registration is optional. It takes effect only on death, and the testator can revoke or change it at any time before that.

Side by side

Will or gift deed for a parent's property
PointGift deedWill
When ownership moves On registration and acceptance Only after the parent's death
Can it be changed? Generally no Yes, any time
Registration Compulsory Optional
Stamp duty in Bengaluru ₹5,000 fixed for listed family members, plus cess, surcharge and fee No stamp duty to make a will
Parent's control during life Gone, unless rights are reserved in the deed Keeps full control
Risk of later dispute Lower on title, since the transfer is complete Higher, since a will can be challenged after death
Khata and records Updated soon after the gift Updated after death, through succession or probate steps

Stamp duty figures are from Article 28 of the Karnataka Stamp Act as explained on our gift deed page, which also lists who counts as family.

When does a gift deed make sense?

  • The parent is sure about the decision and does not need the flat as security for later borrowing.
  • There is one child, or all children agree in writing on who gets what.
  • The child wants to take a loan on the flat or sell it soon, which is easier with a registered title in their name.
  • The family wants the khata, tax and utility records in the child's name now.

Some parents reserve the right to live in the flat for life inside the gift deed. Ask your lawyer how that clause affects a future sale or loan.

When does a will make sense?

  • The parent wants to keep control, rent the flat out, or sell it later.
  • Circumstances may change: a child abroad, a remarriage, a grandchild's needs.
  • The parent wants to divide several assets in one document.

The weak point of a will is that it is tested only after death, when the person who made it cannot explain it. A registered will, clear witnesses and a lawyer's note of the testator's health on the date reduce that risk. Banks and buyers may later ask for probate or a succession process, so ask your lawyer what heirs will need.

What about tax?

A gift of property from a parent to a child is generally not taxed in the child's hands because of the exemption for gifts from relatives, and inheritance under a will is not taxed as income either. Tax comes later, when the child sells. The child's cost and holding period then usually trace back to the parent's purchase. Those rules are technical, so let a CA confirm them for your case.

A middle path some families use

Some parents make a will now and convert part of it into a gift later, for example when a child needs the flat for a loan. Others gift one flat and leave the rest by will. Whatever you choose, write it down, register what needs registration, and tell all children. Most property fights we hear about start with a surprise, not with the document itself. For records after a transfer, see khata transfer and why a society nomination is not a will.

Frequently asked questions

Generally no. Once a registered gift is accepted, it can be revoked only in limited cases the law allows, such as a condition agreed in the deed that fails. Treat it as permanent.

Registration of a will is optional under Indian law. Registering it and having clear witnesses makes it harder to dispute, so many families choose to register.

For a gift to a listed family member within Bengaluru limits, Article 28 of the Karnataka Stamp Act sets a fixed ₹5,000 stamp duty, plus cess, surcharge and registration fee.

Generally no, because gifts from relatives are exempt. The child may pay capital gains tax when they later sell. Confirm the details with a chartered accountant.

Yes, if the gift deed reserves a right of residence or similar right. Ask your lawyer how that clause affects a later sale or loan by the child.

A registered gift completed during the parent's lifetime is usually harder to unsettle than a will, which is tested only after death. Clear drafting and witnesses help both.

Making a will carries no stamp duty. Heirs may later face costs for probate or succession steps and for updating records, so it is not free over the whole process.

No, only the donor signs and the donee accepts. Getting other children to record their agreement in writing reduces the risk of later disputes.

The bank holds the title deeds as security, so you need its consent first. Most banks require the loan to be closed or transferred before a gift is registered.

No. A nomination tells the society whom to deal with after death. It does not decide ownership, which follows the will or the law of succession.

References

  1. Transfer of Property Act, 1882, India Code: https://www.indiacode.nic.in/handle/123456789/2338, accessed 17 Nov 2026
  2. Indian Succession Act, 1925, India Code: https://www.indiacode.nic.in/handle/123456789/2385, accessed 17 Nov 2026
  3. Registration Act, 1908, India Code: https://www.indiacode.nic.in/handle/123456789/2190, accessed 17 Nov 2026
  4. Department of Stamps and Registration, Karnataka: https://igr.karnataka.gov.in/, accessed 17 Nov 2026

This page explains public rules and processes. It isn't legal or tax advice. acre&key gives buyers advice for free.

Was this answer helpful?
Thank you for your feedback!